A print proof checklist for shared postcards: what to check on 16 ads, how to get every advertiser's sign-off in writing, and what to do if you find a mistake.
The proof lands in your inbox and it looks amazing. Sixteen local businesses, all lined up, colors popping. You're two clicks from sending it to print. Hold on. Whatever is on that screen is about to be printed 5,000 times and stuffed into 5,000 mailboxes, typos included. This print proof checklist is the ten minutes that stands between you and a very awkward phone call with an advertiser.
Here's the thing. Most proof checklists online were written for booklets, banners, or branded t-shirts. A shared postcard is a different animal. You don't have one phone number to check. You have sixteen. Sixteen offers, sixteen addresses, sixteen business owners who will absolutely notice if their name is spelled wrong.
A proof is the printer's picture of exactly what they're about to print. It's your last chance to catch anything. Once you approve it, the press runs what you approved.
When you print through 9x12 Method Printing, you upload your file and our print team sends a digital proof, usually within 1 business day. Nothing prints until you approve it. And when you do approve, you tick a box that says, word for word: "I checked proof 1 and it's ready to print exactly as shown. I understand it can't be changed after I approve it." Then you type your full name.
That's not us being dramatic. Amsterdam Printing's own proof approval checklist says it plainly: once printing begins, a reprint is usually unavoidable.
A digital proof is a PDF. A hard proof is a physical printed sample. When you print a 9x12 card with us, a digital proof is what you'll get, and it's enough if you check it the right way (on a big screen, zoomed in, plus one paper printout at home).
Two things a digital proof can't show you:
Exact color. Your screen makes color with light (RGB). The press makes it with ink (CMYK). A bright screen blue can print a little duller. If a brand color really matters to an advertiser, check the color values in your design file, not how it looks on your laptop.
How it feels. Paper and gloss only show up in your hands. Our cards print on 14pt cardstock with UV gloss, so if you've held one of our samples, you already know.
Okay so this is where shared postcards get tricky. On a normal print job there's one customer and one approval. On a 9x12 card there are seventeen people who need to be happy: sixteen advertisers and you.
So you run two rounds of proofs. Let me break it down.
Collect each advertiser's logo, phone number, address, offer, and photos by email right after they pay. One channel. Not text, not Facebook, not a napkin.
Build their slot and send them a proof of just their ad.
Get the word "APPROVED" back in writing, on that same email thread.
Once all sixteen slots are approved, build the full card and upload it to the printer.
Run the print proof checklist below on the printer's proof of the whole card, then approve it yourself.
Round one protects you from the advertiser. Round two protects you from yourself.
I talk about this all the time, because it's the part that drives operators the craziest. You send an ad. They reply with changes. You fix it. They reply again. By round three or four, half the feedback is coming in by text, half by email, and half by Facebook DM at 11 p.m. (Yes, that's three halves. That's how it feels.)
Then the card mails and an advertiser says, "I never approved that typo. Why'd you print it?" And now you're digging through six weeks of messages trying to prove they did.
Michael, one of our members, has a rule that fixes this for good. Every advertiser confirms in writing that they reviewed their ad, approved the final design, and understand you're not responsible for their sales results. His words:
Make sure every advertiser signs off with APPROVED before you send anything to print.
Put that same line in your advertising agreement so it's settled before you ever design a thing.
Here's a simple version you can copy. Send it on the same email thread where they sent you their info.
Subject: Your ad proof for the [Town] card, please reply APPROVED by [day]
"Hi [Name], your ad is attached. Before it goes to print, please check your business name, phone number, address, website, offer, prices, and any dates, and scan the QR code with your phone. If anything needs to change, just reply with the change. If it's perfect, reply with the word APPROVED by [day]. By approving, you're confirming you reviewed your ad and approved the final design, and that results from the ad aren't guaranteed. Thanks! [Your name]"
That last sentence is Michael's rule in plain English. And the day you give them should be a few days before your real print date.
Here's the actual list. Go through it in this order, once on screen at 200% zoom and once on a paper printout. Everything on our own order page's proof list is here, plus the checks that only matter on a shared card and an EDDM mailer.
Business names, spelled exactly the way the owner spells them. "Smith's" vs. "Smiths" matters to Smith.
Every phone number, digit by digit. Then actually call each one. If it rings the wrong place, you find out today instead of after 5,000 homes do.
Every address and website. Did anyone move, rebrand, or change their domain since they sent you their info?
Every QR code. Scan each one with your phone and make sure it lands on the right page. Then scan it with a second phone.
Prices, offers, and dates. Does each price sit next to the right item? Will each expiration date still be in the future when the card actually lands?
Logos and photos. Zoom in. Anything fuzzy or jagged at 200% will look worse on paper.
Nothing important near the edges. Text, phone numbers, and QR codes stay at least 0.25" inside the trim, per our 9x12 postcard print specs.
The whole card, not just the slots. Are the ads lined up? Same spacing? Does anything look off-center when you step back?
The mailing panel. "Postal Customer" and the EDDM indicia are both there, and the word "Postcard" isn't (details below).
The right file. Front and back are both there, they're the latest version, and the card size and quantity on the order are right.
On one of our group calls, someone shared the old printer's trick for catching typos: read everything backwards. Last word first. Your brain stops "reading" the sentence and starts looking at each word, so the misspelled ones jump out.
Here's a story that'll make you check twice. Bruce, one of our members, designed an ad for a bar that had just moved. He showed the ad to the bartender. He showed it to the owner. Both said it looked great.
Then he dropped off a printed card and the owner said, "Oh, all this stuff is wrong." The address was wrong, and the prices for their specials were swapped onto the wrong items. Bruce owned it: those were his mistakes in the design. But as he put it, a good time to talk about that would have been three weeks ago when he asked if the ad was okay.
The lucky break? The QR code pointed to the bar's real location on Google Maps, so it still sent people to the right place.
So two people looked at that ad and said yes, and nobody caught it. People skim their own ads. They know what it's supposed to say, so that's what they see. You are the last set of eyes. Act like it.
This is the stuff a general print checklist won't tell you, and it's the stuff that can get your mailing turned away at the counter.
If you're mailing through EDDM Retail, check the mailing panel on your proof for all of these:
"Postal Customer" is on it. That's the address line USPS allows instead of names and street addresses. "Local Postal Customer" is fine too.
The EDDM Retail indicia is on it. It reads PRSRT STD (or PRSRT MKT), ECRWSS, U.S. POSTAGE, PAID, EDDM Retail. USPS says it goes above and to the right of the address line, in all caps. You need both the address line and the EDDM indicia, not one or the other.
The word "Postcard" is NOT on it. In USPS terms, a 9x12 is a flat, not a postcard. The Domestic Mail Manual says mail that isn't a postcard must not carry the word "Postcard" (DMM 101.6.2.3). If your design says "Postcard" anywhere, take it off before you approve.
Nothing is crowding the mailing panel. Ads that creep into that space make the address and indicia hard to read.
Even with our All Inclusive service, where we handle the bundling and the Post Office paperwork, look for these on the proof yourself. It takes thirty seconds.
Before you approve, a mistake costs you nothing but a little time. Fix it in your design file, export a new PDF, and upload the corrected file. On our order page, it goes straight to the print team and a new proof shows up, usually within 1 business day. If you'd rather explain the problem than fix it yourself, you can send a note instead, and it comes to me.
After you approve, it's a race. Email us right away. If the cards haven't printed yet, we'll do our best to catch it. Once the press runs, though, the only fix is a reprint.
So who pays for that reprint? Across the print industry, the general rule of thumb goes like this. If the mistake was on the proof you approved, it's usually yours. If the printed cards don't match the proof you approved, that's usually on the printer. That's exactly why the proof matters so much: it's the record of what everyone agreed to.
The proof is the contract. Whatever you approve is what prints.
This one's real. Some advertisers are slow on approvals because they're busy running their business. A plumber is under a sink, not reading your email.
So give them a deadline that leaves you room. If your card needs to go to print on Friday, ask for approvals by Tuesday. And remember this order of operations: no "APPROVED," no print. If someone goes silent, call or text to nudge them, but get the APPROVED back on the email thread, and don't approve the full card with their slot unconfirmed.
Sometimes speed is on your side, too. Michael once had an advertiser drop out right at his print deadline. He walked into a countertop shop, sold the slot, designed the ad that night, got approval the next morning, and sent the card to print. A tight deadline doesn't mean skipping the sign-off. It means getting it fast.
A typo doesn't usually cost you the whole card. It costs you something sneakier: the renewal. A 9x12 card is about 16 slots at $500, so $8,000 in revenue, and $5,001 in profit after the $2,999 All Inclusive print and mail to 5,000 homes. Every slot that doesn't renew is $500 you have to go sell again next month. An advertiser whose phone number was wrong probably isn't coming back next month. Advertiser renewals are where this business gets easy, and a clean card is how you earn them.
Look, I'm nothing special at design and you don't need to be either. If building ads isn't your thing, there's a $25 per ad design service with unlimited revisions. You still check the proof, though. Every time.
Full transparency: I do teach the whole design and approval process inside the community, and stories like Bruce's come straight from our group calls. You don't need it to run this checklist. But hearing how other operators got burned is a cheap way to not get burned yourself.
If you want to make your ads better before they even get to the proof stage, my guide on postcard ad design tips covers phone number size, offers, and layout. And if you want each advertiser to see real scans after the card lands, a trackable QR code on every slot does that.
Check every name, phone number, address, website, QR code, price, offer, and date, then logos and photos at 200% zoom. Make sure nothing important sits within 0.25" of the edge, the whole card is lined up, and the EDDM mailing panel has "Postal Customer" and the indicia. Call every phone number and scan every QR code instead of just reading them.
Every printer has its own button, so use theirs, and don't assume a reply to the proof email counts as approval. On our order page, you review the proof, tick a box confirming it's ready to print exactly as shown, type your full name, and click approve. It goes to print right after that.
Usually not. Approval tells the printer to start. If you spot something right after approving, contact the printer immediately, because it may still be caught before the press runs. Once the cards are printed, the only fix is a reprint.
Generally, if the typo was on the proof you approved, you pay for the reprint. If the printed cards don't match the approved proof, the printer should make it right. On a shared card, that's why each advertiser should approve their own ad in writing before you approve the full card.
Screens make color with light (RGB) and printing presses use ink (CMYK), so some bright screen colors print slightly duller. Design in CMYK from the start, and if a brand color matters to an advertiser, match the color values rather than trusting how it looks on your monitor.
Collect everything by email right after they pay, send a proof of their ad on that same thread, and ask them to reply with the word "APPROVED." Give them a deadline a few days before your real print date, and follow up by phone if they go quiet. Put the approval step in your advertising agreement so it's expected from day one.
Ten minutes with this list beats 5,000 cards with the wrong phone number on them. Check it twice, get it in writing, then go mail that thing. As always, I'm rooting for you.
Ready to run your own card?
Get the course, scripts, tools, and weekly coaching inside the 9x12 Method community.